Ask the Minutes Maven
No question too basic. No board too dysfunctional. Ask away.
The questions here are drawn from real conversations, coaching sessions, and thirty years of working with boards. Names and locations are changed to protect the people brave enough to ask. The problems are not.
How would a tool that wasn't in the room know what actually matters to my organization?
A tool without organizational context has a real limitation, but so do most human minute takers, since the person holding the pen is often new to the role or the organization. The solution isn't avoiding tools, it's ensuring someone with real context reviews every draft before it becomes the official record.
– Skeptical in Skowhegan
I asked to see our Form 990 before we voted and got called meddling. Was I overreacting?
Asking is the job, not an overstep. Form 990 asks whether the governing body reviewed the return, so your vote to approve attests that you personally did.
– Not Trying to Be Difficult in Danvers
A longtime board member takes unreadable minutes and won't consider a change. Should I let it go?
No — reframe it. He rejected a tool, not the problem, and as Governance Committee chair, setting a minutes standard for every committee is already his job.
– Thwarted in Tallahassee
The board keeps asking me to change things in the minutes. How do I know who's right?
Board members are not always right about minutes. Your job is not to make everyone happy. It's to produce an accurate legal record of what the board decided.
– Drowning in Drafts in Denver
I've been copying the same minutes format for six years. Am I doing it wrong?
Maybe. "Nobody has complained" is not the same as "this is correct." You may be faithfully reproducing a format that was never quite right to begin with.
– Blissfully Ignorant in Boise
My board doesn't want to be recorded. But without a recording the minutes take forever. What do I do?
Yes, you can change their minds. The argument they're making is about what happens to the recording afterward, not the recording itself. That's a solvable problem.
– Should Be Writing Grants in Greensboro
Can I use AI to take the minutes so I can actually participate in the meeting?
AI can help you significantly. It cannot replace you entirely. Not yet. And the bigger problem here isn't the technology.
– The Only One in Ohio
Can I just use the Zoom summary as my board minutes?
No. A Zoom summary is a technology product. Board minutes are a legal document. They are not the same thing, and one cannot substitute for the other.
– Tempted by Technology in Tacoma
Have a question for the Maven?
No question too basic. No board too dysfunctional. Ask away.
Question sent.
Marci reads every one. If yours becomes a Maven column, we'll change your name and details first.
Get the good stuff in your inbox.
Practical guidance for the people who keep boards running. No spam, leave anytime.
You're in.
The next one lands in your inbox.
How does your minutes process stack up?
Take the Board Minutes Reality Check: find out your governance profile and the one thing worth fixing first, plus a free governance guide.